01
Trades sync themselves
MetaTrader 4/5, cTrader, TopstepX, Match-Trader and DXtrade auto-sync; import any CSV. No nightly manual entry, no fiddly statement uploads — your journal is current without the chore.
Comparison
Consistry vs Edgewonk: a coach, not a spreadsheet on steroids
Edgewonk is a beloved, analytically deep journal for traders who love the manual process — custom variables, tag correlations, a trade simulator, and the Tiltmeter for psychology. If you want to hand-craft your self-analysis, it's one of the best at it.
But it's a desktop app with no live broker sync, no AI, no mobile, no cloud — and nothing for the prop-firm world. Consistry automates the boring part (syncing trades), watches your firm's rules for you, and coaches with AI across every challenge.
TL;DR: Pick Edgewonk for hands-on, deep manual journaling on your own machine. Pick Consistry if you want auto-sync, prop-firm rule tracking, an AI coach, and a phone in your pocket.
Quick comparison
| Consistry | Edgewonk | |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | Prop-firm traders | Manual self-analysis, retail |
| How trades get in | Auto-sync (MT4/5, cTrader, TopstepX, Match-Trader, DXtrade) + CSV | Manual entry / CSV / MT import — no live sync |
| Free plan | Unlimited logging, no card | Paid only (14-day money-back) |
| Price | Pro $29/mo · 14-day free trial | ~$197/year subscription |
| Prop firm rule & drawdown tracking | Daily / max / trailing, per challenge | |
| Cross-challenge / multi-account memory | All firms = one trader profile | |
| AI coach cited to your trades | Insights, daily plan, weekly analysis | Stats + Tiltmeter, no AI |
| Pre-trade rule check | GREEN / YELLOW / RED before you enter | |
| Mobile app | iOS & Android (+ voice coach) | Desktop app only |
| Cloud / log anywhere | Cloud — web + phone, synced | Local data, tied to one machine |
Where Edgewonk is genuinely better
Edgewonk is a craftsman's tool. For traders who want to go deep by hand, it shines.
Manual analytical depth.
Custom variables and tags, tag correlations, R-multiple/expectancy, 50+ customizable reports. Among the deepest hand-built analysis in the category.
The trade simulator.
What-if testing of exits, sizing and scenarios on your own history — rare and genuinely useful.
Tiltmeter & psychology.
A mature behavioral system that correlates your logged emotional state with outcomes — structured discipline for those who'll be honest with it.
Local data ownership.
A desktop app with local data appeals to privacy-minded traders who don't want their journal in the cloud.
Where Consistry wins for prop traders
02
It speaks prop firm
Daily-loss, max and trailing drawdown, profit targets, challenge phases, fees and payouts — tracked per account. Edgewonk has nothing for prop rules.
03
AI that coaches
Cited-to-your-trades insights, a morning plan, a weekly pattern report, and a pre-trade GREEN/YELLOW/RED check. Edgewonk's analysis is powerful but entirely manual.
04
One trader, every firm
All your prop firms and your personal account as a single profile — patterns that single-account journals can't see.
05
Cloud + mobile + voice
Log and review from web or phone, anywhere, and talk through trades with a voice coach. Edgewonk is a single-machine desktop app.
Who should pick which
Pick Edgewonk if: you love deep manual journaling, want a trade simulator and custom-variable analysis on your own machine, and don't need auto-sync, prop tools, AI or mobile.
Pick Consistry if: you grind prop challenges, want trades to sync automatically, your firm's rules watched for you, and an AI coach on web and phone — starting free.
FAQ
For prop-firm traders who want automation and AI — yes. If you specifically want hands-on manual journaling with a simulator and local data, Edgewonk is excellent at that. Consistry is built for prop traders who'd rather the journal do the work.
Not via a live connection — Edgewonk is import/manual (CSV and MetaTrader statements), and reviewers describe its integrations as finicky. Consistry auto-syncs MetaTrader 4/5, cTrader, TopstepX, Match-Trader and DXtrade, and imports any CSV.
No — it predates prop firms and has no challenge, drawdown or payout tracking. That's the core of Consistry.
No longer — its pricing is now an annual subscription (~$197/yr). Consistry has a free plan and Pro from $29/mo with a 14-day trial.
Let the journal do the work
Start free — auto-sync your prop accounts, every firm in one profile, no card required.