ConsistryMyfxbook has been a staple of the forex world for years: connect via your MetaTrader investor password and it publishes a verified, shareable track record with deep stats, plus AutoTrade copy-trading. If your goal is a public, provable performance page, it's excellent — and free.
But a verified equity curve isn't a coaching journal. Prop trading is about surviving rules that change between firms, accounts that reset every few weeks, and challenge fees that eat your real ROI. That's the problem Consistry is built for — and it's not what Myfxbook was designed to do.
TL;DR: Myfxbook verifies your track record. Consistry coaches you through the challenge.
| Consistry | Myfxbook | |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | Prop firm traders | Forex track record & social |
| Price | Free forever + Premium $15/mo (14-day trial) | Free (ad-supported) |
| Cross-challenge memory | One trader profile across every account & firm | Per-account equity curves, no challenge model |
| Prop firm rule & drawdown tracking | Daily / max / trailing + profit target, per firm | General drawdown stats, no rule engine |
| Pre-trade Green Light | GREEN / YELLOW / RED before you enter | Analytics are after the fact |
| AI coach | Cited to your own trades, included in Premium | Not offered |
| Challenge fees & payout ROI | Across all firms, any currency | Not tracked |
| Broker auto-sync | MT4/5, cTrader, TopstepX, Match-Trader, DXtrade, TradeLocker, Tradovate & NinjaTrader + any CSV | MT4/5 via investor password (forex-first) |
| Verified public track record | Shareable trader card, not a verification service | Its signature strength |
| Copy trading / AutoTrade | AutoTrade marketplace | |
| Asset coverage | Forex-first (prop focus) | Forex-first |
No spin — Myfxbook wins if:
Its read-only verification of a live MT4/MT5 account is the industry standard for proving results to others. Consistry gives you a shareable trader card, not third-party verification.
AutoTrade lets you follow or be followed. Consistry doesn't do copy trading — it's a journal and coach, not a marketplace.
For a single MT4/MT5 account and classic stats, Myfxbook is free and battle-tested.
If that's you, use Myfxbook. It's genuinely good at it.
Myfxbook shows you a drawdown number. Consistry tracks the specific rules that decide whether you keep the account — daily loss, max loss, trailing drawdown, profit target and consistency — per firm, and warns you as you approach the line.
A verified equity curve tells you what already happened. Consistry's pre-trade check compares your setup against your strategy, your prop firm's rules and your recent trades, and returns GREEN, YELLOW or RED before you click buy.
In Myfxbook, a blown account is a dead equity curve. In Consistry, every challenge — passed, failed, active, across every firm — feeds one trader profile, so the AI can see that both your blown accounts died the same way and warn you before the next one does.
Three failed $500 challenges are part of the business. Consistry tracks fees and payouts across all firms and currencies, so you know your actual ROI — something a track-record tool doesn't model.
Prop firms run more than MT4/MT5. Consistry auto-syncs cTrader, TopstepX, Match-Trader, DXtrade, TradeLocker, Tradovate and NinjaTrader too — or imports any CSV — so your journal isn't limited to the platforms an investor password reaches.
Pick Myfxbook if: you want a free, verified public track record on a MetaTrader account, or you're into copy trading via AutoTrade, and you don't need prop-rule tracking or coaching.
Pick Consistry if: you're grinding prop challenges, you need to track each firm's rules and fees, and you want an AI that remembers your patterns across every challenge — starting free.
Free forever plan, no card required. 14-day Premium trial if you want the AI coach and full auto-sync.