ConsistryTrademetria is a mature, multi-asset trading journal with solid portfolio tracking, performance analytics and a free tier. If you trade a personal account across stocks, futures and crypto and want a broad, established journal, it's a reasonable pick — and we'll say when.
But Trademetria is a general journal. It doesn't model the thing that defines prop trading: challenges that reset, firm-specific rules that end the account, and fees that shape your real ROI. That gap is exactly what Consistry was built to close.
TL;DR: Trademetria journals your portfolio. Consistry runs your prop challenge.
| Consistry | Trademetria | |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | Prop firm traders | General multi-asset traders |
| Free plan | Free forever, unlimited trades | Free tier with limits |
| Prop firm rule & drawdown tracking | Daily / max / trailing + profit target, per firm | Not a prop-rule engine |
| Cross-challenge memory | One trader profile across every account & firm | Portfolio/account view, not challenge-based |
| Pre-trade Green Light | GREEN / YELLOW / RED before you enter | Post-trade analytics only |
| AI coach over your trades | Cited to your own history, included in Premium | Analytics, not a cited AI coach |
| Challenge fees & payout ROI | Across all firms, any currency | Not modeled |
| Prop platform auto-sync | MT4/5, cTrader, TopstepX, Match-Trader, DXtrade, TradeLocker, Tradovate & NinjaTrader | Broker connections + CSV, retail-focused |
| Asset coverage | Forex & futures first (prop focus) | Stocks, futures, forex, crypto |
No spin — Trademetria wins if:
Its multi-asset portfolio tracking across stocks, futures and crypto is broad and mature — handy if your trading isn't prop-focused.
Trademetria has been around for years with a stable feature set. If you just want a dependable generalist, it delivers.
Its reporting leans toward portfolio and equity-curve analysis, which suits a single growing account.
If that's you, Trademetria is a solid choice.
Trademetria shows you performance. Consistry tracks the specific rules that decide whether you keep the account — daily loss, max loss, trailing drawdown, profit target and consistency — per firm and phase, and warns you before you breach.
Portfolio analytics tell you what already happened. Consistry's pre-trade check compares your setup against your strategy, your firm's rules and your recent trades and returns GREEN, YELLOW or RED before you click buy.
In a general journal, a blown account is just a closed account. In Consistry, every challenge across every firm feeds one trader profile, so the AI can see both your blown accounts died the same way and warn you before the next one does.
Three failed $500 challenges are part of the business. Consistry tracks fees and payouts across all firms and currencies, so you know your actual ROI — not just the equity curve of the account that's alive.
Consistry auto-syncs MetaTrader 4/5, cTrader, TopstepX, Match-Trader, DXtrade, TradeLocker, Tradovate and NinjaTrader — the platforms prop firms actually run — or imports any CSV. Free plan is free forever; Premium is $15/mo with everything included.
Pick Trademetria if: you trade a personal account across many asset classes, want a mature general journal with portfolio tracking, and don't need prop-firm rule compliance.
Pick Consistry if: you run prop-firm challenges, you need each firm's rules and fees tracked, and you want an AI that remembers your patterns across every challenge — starting free.
Free forever plan, no card required. 14-day Premium trial if you want the AI coach and auto-sync.